structure, culture, and agency

 

agency:     --what humans do to break free of, manipulate, change, or play with, the structural and cultural conditions they face

 

structural factors:

 

A)      --"structure" as distributions of types of persons or classes

            --key point: we can know something about a group's dynamic w/o knowing anything about the individuals comprising it

            --(population) density

            --age ratios

            --sex ratios, i.e. male:female

            --other kinds of population ratios, or distributions:

                   E.G. black:white,

                          ethnic albanian:ethnic serb,

                          palestinian:jew

                  --think of a ‘tipping game’

more on properties to look for in the depiction of social structures:

                  --ratio of elite:mass       

            --layering, or stratification, i.e.,

                    number of layers, or: distance   between layers

                  --ascriptive vs achieved status

                  --degree of formal vs. informal

                   stratification

 

 

      examples to think about:

1)           birth order

2)           age ratios and Social Security

3)           job searches and qualifications

 

 

 


 

B)         --"structure" as 'patterns of interactions': or: SOCIAL NETWORKS

                                                          i.      the analysis of groups ‘1’, ‘2’, and ‘3’ from Stark/overheads

 

      --again, the key point: we can know something about a group's dynamic w/o knowing anything about the individuals comprising it

 

 

Further ideas about networks:

--segmentary opposition (e.g. tribal structure, cheering for sports teams?)

                  --strong versus weak ties;

                  --bridge ties vs. reinforcement ties, or ‘internal’ ties

                  --the value of redundancy

                  --existence of structural holes

                        --e.g.: airline travel

                        --e.g.: fedex

 

            --“small world networks”

                        --e.g.: "6 degrees of separation"

                        --“6 Degrees of Kevin Bacon”

 

      --networks and IDENTITIES

            --cosmopolitan vs provincial

--brokerage and social control; for example, Hakim
--tension (suburban gays) (Wayne Brekhus’ research )

--fringe actors (hangers-on, nicknames)

 

 


Cultural factors:

 

  --culture:physiology = software:hardware, and maybe:

  --culture:structure = software:hardware

 

            --examples: play, eating, vendetta

 

      --think of culture as being like recipes, blueprints, or plans

 

      --a medium for interpreting, and responding to, our surroundings: a kind of "TOOLKIT"

 

      --comprised of language, other tools, symbols, habits, practices, attitudes, roles, values, shared points of contention, etc.

 

      --today less emphasis on values and habits, and more emphasis on symbols, toolkits, and cognition (mental organization of the world)

--Italian vs. Jewish experience

1)           cultural values said to be different

2)           no: achievement in occupational hierarchy back home was key for Jews

3)           no: holding achievement constant, there is still a Jewish edgeà attributed to where their reference group was located, where they were mentally invested, lack of opportunity to go home