History 506:364

Colonialism to Globalization
Spring 2003
Monday & Thursday
9:50 - 11:10
 

Professor
Gail D. Triner

VanDyck Hall 002C
932-6696
triner@ix.netcom.com
http://www.rci.rutgers.edu/~triner

Teaching Assistant
Louisa Rice
VanDyck Hall 009
rice@history.rutgers.edu

Office Hours:
Mon., 11:30-12:30Mon., 4:30-5:30
Other times, by appointment

Mon., 1-2:30
Other times, by appointment

 

 

At least since the 17th century the European world has categorized it global relations with a fundamental divide between “us” and “them.”  The names have changed for this categorization; some of them are: Empire and Colony; First, Second and Third Worlds; North and South; Industrialized and Emerging.  This course will look at these ways of categorizing international relations, and the people they involve, from the non-European perspective – from the perspective of the colonies, the Third World, the South… 

We will address three broad themes through the semester: (1) defining these concepts, and their differences and commonalities; (2) national identity; and (3) the impact of these abstract concepts on the lives of individuals.  We will consider both theoretical issues and look at specific examples, using the experiences of Brazil, Peru, Nigeria, and occasionally other countries.  Throughout we will focus both on the relationship of “the South” to “the North” and the perspectives which have arisen from within “the South.”

Class sessions will include lectures, discussions, and visual materials.  The readings and lectures for this course draw upon a very wide diversity of sources.  Because the topic of the course covers a very long time period and large geography we will investigate selective themes in a variety of settings. Grades will be based on a take-home mid-term, a take final exam, two short papers and class participation.

            A day or two before each class session, I will post a highly summarized outline of the issues that I expect each class to cover on the web page for this class. (You can get to this site by going through the links on my home page, see address above.) I intend for these very broad outlines to help you begin thinking about the issues that we will cover in class. (Or, if you miss class, give you some indication of what you miss.) You should not rely on these outlines as exhaustive descriptions for classes. And you should, especially, not rely on them as a substitute for class attendance. Depending on how any class session actually progresses, we may not cover the issues in the order that they appear; and we may use different words and phrases to cover the concepts.

Course Requirements

The requirements for the course (with their respective proportion of the final grade) are:

%grade

25% each         2 Take-home mid-semester exams
40%                 Take-home final exam
10%                 Class participation

Readings

Book

Achebe; No Longer at Ease (novel)

Course Packet - Volume 1

Holton; Globalization and the Nation-State; Ch. 1; pp 1-20

Merriam; “What does ‘Third World’ Mean?” in Norwine and Gonzalex (eds.) The Third World: States of Mind and Being; pp. 15-22. [NOT a required reading]

Concolorcorvo Engages the Postal Inspector about Indian Affairs,” in K. Mills & W. Taylor (eds.), Colonial Spanish America: A Documentary History; pp. 282-87.

Morley; Colonial Postscript: Diary of a District Officer, 1935-56, Chs. 2& 3; pp. 21-67.

Walker, C. “The Patriotic Society: Discussions and Omissions about Indians in the Peruvian War of Independence;” in The Americas, 55:2; pp. 275-98.

Johnson “Grass Roots Organizing: Women in Anticolonial Activities in Southwestern Nigeria,” in African Studies Review, vol. 25, nos. 2&3; pp. 137-57.

Falola, The History of Nigeria, Chapter 6; pp.81-93.

Gootenberg, Imagining Development Ch. 1; pp. 1-21.

Dean, The Industrialization of São Paulo: 1880-1945; Ch. 1; pp.3-15

Falola, The History of Nigeria, Ch. 8; pp. 115-36.

Amadi, Sunset in Biafra: A Civil War Diary.

Course Pack - Volume 2

Aluko, “Nigeria and the Superpowers,” Millennium-Journal of International Studies vol. 5, no. 2; pp. 127-41.

Gunder Frank, “The Development of Underdevelopment,” Ch. 1 in Cockcroft, Gunder Frank & Johnson, (eds.) Dependency and Underdevelopment: Latin America’s Political Economy; pp. 3-17.

Selections from Peru Reader; Starn, Degregori & Kirk (eds.), Section VI, “The Shining Path.;” pp. 305-35.

“Fatal Attraction: Peru’s Shining Path” NACLA Report on the Americas; vol. 24, no. 4:   Degregori, “A Dwarf Star” and Andreas, “Women at War;” pp9-15, 20-27.

Keohane & Nye; “Globalization: What’s New? What’s not? (And So What?)” in Foreign Policy #118 (Spring 2000); pp. 104-19.

Castaņeda, “Latin America and the End of the Cold War” in Lowenthal & Treverton (eds.) Latin America in a New World; pp. 28-52.

Jaguaribe, “A View from the Southern Cone” in Lowenthal & Treverton (eds.) Latin America in a New World pp. 53-64.

Van de WalleAfrica and the World Economy: Continued Marginalization or Re-engagement?;Harbeson & Rothchild (eds.) Africa in World Politics; pp. 263-285.

Ojo-Ade; Ken Saro-Wiwa (a bio-critical study), Ch. IX, “The Ogoni Tragedy and Saro-Wiwa’s Commitment;” pp. 259-80.

 

Notes:

  • Achebe, No Longer at Ease and Amadi, Sunset in Biafra are available at the Alexander Library Undergraduate Reserve Reading Desk.
  • All other readings are, I hope, available as pdf files through the Alexander Library electronic reserves. (Follow this link for instructions on using electronic reserves.) You can follow hyperlinks from the on-line version of the syllabus to go directly to the readings.

To use electronic reserves from a computer that is NOT connected to the Rutgers servers (i.e.; from off-campus,) you need to configure your computer for remote access to the Rutgers Library system. To do so, follow this link to the instructions (and follow them carefully.)

 

CLASS SESSIONS

 

The dates indicated throughout the syllabus are my “best guess” about the pace we will keep through the semester. If I find that we need to adjust these dates, or the reading assignments, I will let you know as soon as possible.

 Follow this link to class session outlines.

I Introduction

(2 classes)

  Read Holton; Globalization and the Nation-State, Ch. 1.

See also this brief definition of Third World

  Questions      What do these authors mean by “Third World” and “globalization”? Can you suggest alternative terms? Why does it matter how we refer to these ideas and countries?
II Empire & colony

(3 classes)

  Read Concolorcorvo Engages the Postal Inspector about Indian Affairs.”

Morley; Colonial Postscript: Diary of a District Officer, 1935-56.

  Discussion Groups Come to last class of this section prepared to explore in small discussion groups questions raised by these readings. (Questions will be distributed in class)
  Question  From these readings, how did colonial administrators and their local populations perceive each other? Identify, and give examples of, any commonalities you find between Peru and Nigeria.
III Independence

(3 classes)

  Read Walker, C. “The Patriotic Society: Discussions and Omissions about Indians in the Peruvian War of Independence.”

Falola, The History of Nigeria, Ch. 6.

Johnson “Grass Roots Organizing: Women in Anticolonial Activities in Southwestern Nigeria.”

Gootenberg, Imagining Development: Economic Ideas in Peru’s ‘Fictitious Prosperity of Guano, 1840-1880; Ch. 1, pp. 1-21.

Dean, The Industrialization of São Paulo: 1880-1945; Ch. 1

  Questions 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                 

These readings (especially those by Walker, Falola and Johnson) consider a wide variety of activities that underpinned the independence movements of Peru and Nigeria. Use the readings to consider

1.       some of the compromises to the concept of “independence” faced by colonized peoples

2.       the role of gender in participating in these independence movements.

 

How were guano and coffee important for shaping the independence of Peru and Brazil? What seem to have been the major differences between the impacts of guano and coffee?

  Personal reality
  Read No Longer at Ease

Note: This novel is available at the reserve desk (Alexander Library) and at the bookstore; it is not available as either an electronic reserve or in the course pack.

You may be interested in reading this interview with Chinua Achebe, the author of No Longer at Ease (on-line)

  Discussion Groups Come to class prepared to explore in small discussion groups questions raised by these readings. (Questions will be distributed in class.)
  20 Feb. 1st mid-term exam will be distributed at the end of class.
  24 Feb. First mid-term exam review session.
  27 Feb. First mid-term exam is due at beginning of class, as we begin session on “Nation formation.”
IV Nation formation

(2 classes)

  Read Canudos

Photos of Canudos (look at photos - text is in Portuguese)

Falola, The History of Nigeria, Ch. 8

Amadi, Sunset in Biafra: A Civil War Diary

Note:  Sunset in Biafra is now available through electronic reserves in the following files:

Additional personal experiences with, and background on, the Biafran Civil War:

Women’s accounts

Through the Lens of History: Biafra, Nigeria, the West and the World

  Question   Contrast the ideas and ideals that underpinned the Nigerian post-independence civil war with the experience of living through the war. How did the years leading up to independence affect the issues involved in the civil war?
V The Third World

(3 classes)

  Read Aluko, “Nigeria and the Superpowers”

Gunder Frank, “The Development of Underdevelopment”

 

 

In what ways did the Cold War matter for Nigeria? Were some Nigerians able to use the Cold War to their advantage. If so, how?

"The Development of Underdevelopment" has become a major expression of "dependency theory." In the context of the Third World, what is dependency? Explore the manners in which Gunder Frank argues that economic dependency shapes society in the Third World

 

HAVE A NICE SPRING BREAK
  Personal realities in the Third World

(4 classes)

  Read Selections from Peru Reader; Starn, Degregori & Kirk (eds.), Section VI, “The Shining Path”

 Degregori, “Fatal Attraction: Peru’s Shining Path” and Andreas, “Women at War” (These articles should be in the same electronic file.)

Index of Shining Path sources that you may be interested in browsing.

Shining Path and drug trafficking

  Questions  

 

 

 

 

 

 

The readings on the Shining Path reveal much about the thinking actions of its members, sympathizers and resisters. The readings refer to linkages with Marxism, political organization and economic issues. Write an essay that:

1.       considers the ways in which the actions and thoughts of the Shining Path may be extreme expressions of dependency theory

2.       explores the motivations of individuals associated with the Shining Path. (This may offer an especially rich opportunity to consider the roles of race and gender, both male and female, in this social revolution.)

  Film and discussion Within this section, we will see a film and have a class session of small group discussion.
  3 Apr. Second mid-term exam will be distributed at end of class session.
  7 Apr. Second mid-term exam review session.
  10 Apr. Second mid-term exam is due at beginning of class session, as we begin section on Globalization.
VI Globalization

(3 classes)

  Read Keohane & Nye “Globalization: What’s New? What’s Not? (And So What?)”

Castaņeda, “Latin America and the End of the Cold War: An Essay in Frustration”

Jaguaribe, “A View from the Southern Cone”

Van de Walle “Africa and the World Economy…”

Gen. Babaguinda, Ethnic Nationalities & Nigeria, Dec., 2002 9Interesting recent reading on Nigeria)

  Questions

 

 

What is globalization - and what are its historical roots?

Why has the end of the Cold War been important for "emerging"/Third World countries during the recent years of globalization?

  Group discussion We will have one session in small group discussions during this section of the class.
  Personal realities of globalization

(2 classes)

  Read Ojo-Ade; Ken Saro-Wiwa (a bio-critical study) Ch IX “The Ogoni Tragedy …”

For contrasting “stories” on oil, oil companies, environmental and local disputes follow these links to Shell-Nigeria and local communities’ websites. These links will provide more on Ken Saro-Wiwa (& PBS link.)

  Question What are the long-term roots of the problems that the Ogoni people faced in the 1990s?
VII Conclusion & Review
  I will distribute the take-home final exam at the end of class on 1 May.